УДК 316.647.82:342.56                                                                                                                                                   PDF

ORCID: 0000-0002-9800-8785

DOI 10.37566/2707-6849-2020-2(31)-2

Tetiana FULEY,

The Head of Department of the National School of judges of Ukraine, Candidate of Juridicial Sciences,honored lawer of Ukraine

DISCRIMINATION AS A CONSEQUENCE OF THE INFLUENCE OF GENDER STEREOTYPES ON THE REASONING OF A COURT DECISION

The article shows the seriousness of the impact of gender stereotypes on the court’s perception of the position of a party to the trial depending on its sex and age, as well as on the formation of reasons that the court is guided by when evaluating evidence and making decisions.

On the example of the decision of the Grand Chamber of the European Court of Human Rights in the case of Carvalho Pinto de Sousa Morais v. Portugal has demonstrated how gender stereotypes can lead to biased and, as a result, discriminatory judgments, which can lead to a breach of the State’s obligations under the Convention for the Protection of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms. The applicant alleged that the Supreme Administrative Court’s decision to reduce the amount initially awarded to her in respect of nonpecuniary damage had amounted to discrimination on the grounds of sex and age, in breach of Article 14 in conjunction with Article 8 of the Convention. She complained, in particular, about the reasons given by the Supreme Administrative Court for reducing the amount awarded to her and about the fact that it had disregarded the importance of a sex life for her as a woman.

The author has underlined that in the present case the Court’s task was not to analyse the actual amounts awarded to the applicant by the Supreme Administrative Court. The issue which has to be determined, however, is whether or not the Supreme Administrative Court’s reasoning led to a difference of treatment of the applicant based on her sex and age, amounting to a breach of Article 14 in conjunction with Article 8. In the Court’s view, the wording of the Supreme Administrative Court’s judgment when reducing the amount of compensation in respect of non-pecuniary damage expressed the assumption that sexuality is not as important for a fifty-year old woman and mother of two children as for someone of a younger age. That assumption reflects a traditional idea of female sexuality as being essentially linked to child-bearing purposes and thus ignores its physical and psychological relevance for the self-fulfillment of women as people. In the Court’s view, those considerations show the prejudices prevailing amongst the judiciary in Portugal, especially compare to approach taken in two Portuguese judgments of 2008 and 2014, which concerned allegations of medical malpractice by two male patients who were fifty-five and fifty-nine years old respectively.

The case of Carvalho Pinto de Sousa Morais v Portugal is neither only nor the first case addressing the question of gender discrimination in connection with judgments of the national courts, hoverer, the key one. This case proves that gender stereotypes and outdated perception of gender roles played a significant role in judicial assessment and decision-making which can lead to the gender-based discrimination.

Key words: discrimination, sex, age, gender stereotypes, court decision, judgment.

References

Pro zasady zapobihannia ta protydii dyskryminatsii v Ukraini: Zakon Ukrainy vid 6 ver. 2012 r. No. 5207-VI [On the Principles of Preventing and Combating Discrimination in Ukraine: Law of Ukraine of September 6, 2012]. Vidomosti Verkhovnoi Rady Ukrainy, Information of the Verkhovna Rada of Ukraine, 2013, No. 32, st. 412.

Shcho ukraintsi znaiut i dumaiut pro prava liudyny: otsinka zmin (2016–2018). Reziume doslidzhennia; [What Ukrainians Know and Think of Human Rights: a Progress Study (2016–2018). Research Summary]; S. Kolyshko, M. Parashchevin, V. Yavorskyi]; edited by T. Pechonchyk. Kyiv, 2018. 96 p.

Pro zatverdzhennia Derzhavnoi sotsialnoi prohramy zabezpechennia rivnykh prav ta mozhlyvostei zhinok i cholovikiv na period do 2021 roku: Postanova KMU vid 11 kvitnia 2018 r. No. 273 [On approval of the State social program to ensure equal rights and opportunities for women and men for the period up to 2021: Resolution of the Cabinet of Ministers of April 11, 2018 No. 273]. URL: https://zakon.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/273-2018-%D0%BF#Text

Henderna rivnist i rozvytok: pohliad u konteksti yevropeiskoi stratehii Ukrainy [Gender equality and development: a view in the context of Ukraine’s European strategy]. Kyiv, 2016. 244 p.

Stratehiia hendernoi rivnosti Rady Yevropy na 2018–2023 roky [Council of Europe Gender Equality Strategy for 2018–2023]. URL: https://rm.coe.int/prems-041318-gbr-gender-equality-strategy-2023-ukr-new2/16808b35a4

Sudove vyrishennia sprav u sporakh, poviazanykh iz gendernoiu dyskryminatsiieiu: zbirka krashchykh praktyk. Uporiad.: O. Uvarova, M. Yasenovska [Judicial Resolution in Gender Discrimination Disputes: A Collection of Best Practices. Edited by: O. Uvarova, M. Yasenovska]. Kharkiv, FOP Brovin O.V., 2016. 192 p.

Kotlova T.B., Ryabova T.B. Bybliohraficheskyi obzor issledovaniy po problemam hendernykh stereotipov [Bibliographic review of research on gender stereotypes]. Zhenshchina v rossiyskom obshchestve, A woman in Russian society. 2001. No. 3-4. P. 25-38.

Carvalho Pinto de Sousa Morais v. Portugal, application no. 17484/15, July 25, 2017. URL: http://hudoc.echr.coe.int/eng?i=001-175659

Konstantin Markin v. Russia [Grand Chamber], application no. 30078/06, March 22, 2012. URL: http://hudoc.echr.coe.int/eng?i=001-109868

8-y Mizhnarodnyi forum z praktyky Yevropeiskoho sudu z prav liudyny [8th International Forum on the Case Law of the European Court of Human Rights]. OSCE Project Co-ordinator in Ukraine. November 21, 2019. URL: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KGSlB8x-Iz0&feature=emb_err_watch_on_yt ; 05:30:26-05:35:06.

Marckx v. Belgium, application no. 6833/74, June 13, 1979. URL: http://hudoc.echr.coe.int/eng?i=001-57534

Kuybida R., Syroid O. Posibnyk iz napysannia sudovykh rishen [Guide to writing court decisions]. Kyiv: Drim Art, 2013. 224 p.

Slovnyk ukrainskoi movy: v 11 tomakh [Dictionary of the Ukrainian language: in 11 volumes]. Vol. 10, 1979. URL: http://sum.in.ua/s/umotyvovuvaty

Kryminalnyi protsesualnyi kodeks Ukrainy : Zakon Ukrainy vid 13 kvit. 2012 r. No 4651-VI [Criminal Procedure Code of Ukraine: Law of Ukraine of April 13, 2020, No 4651-VI]. Vidomosti Verkhovnoi Rady Ukrainy, Information of the Verkhovna Rada of Ukraine, 2013, No 9–10, No11–12, No 13, p. 88.

Schuler-Zgraggen v. Switzerland, application no. 14518/89, June, 24, 1993. URL: http://hudoc.echr.coe.int/eng?i=001-57840

Tkalych M. Henderna psykholohiia [Gender psychology]: navch. posib. 2-e vyd., vypr., dopovn. Kyiv : Akademvydav, 2016. 256 p.

Akhmadeyeva K. N. Konstruirovaniye gendernykh stereotipov v upravlenii: tematicheskiy repertuar diskursivnykh praktik i strategiy: avtoref. diss. ... kand. sotsiolog. nauk [The construction of gender stereotypes in management: thematic repertoire of discursive practices and strategies: avtoref. diss. ... cand. sociologist. sciences]: 22.00.08. Kazan’, 2011. 23 p.

Vitlitskaya E. V. Lingvisticheskaya interpretatsiya gendernykh stereotipov v reklame (na materialakh angloyazychnykh i russkoyazychnykh tekstov): avtoref. diss. ... kand. filolog. nauk [Linguistic interpretation of gender stereotypes in advertising (based on English and Russian texts): avtoref. diss. ... cand. philologist. sciences]: 10.00.09. Volgograd, 2005. 24 p.

Fedorova T. V. Gendernyye stereotipy kak faktor formirovaniya imidzha politika: avtoref. diss. ... kand. polit. nauk [Gender stereotypes as a factor in shaping the image of a politician: avtoref. diss. ... cand. political sciences]: 23.00.02. Stavropol’, 2008. 22 s.

Ageyev V. S. Psikhologicheskiye i sotsial’nyye funktsii polorolevykh stereotipov [Psychological and social functions of sex-role stereotypes]. Voprosy psikhologii, Psychology issues.1987. No 2. P. 152–157.

Ryabova T. B. Gendernyye stereotipy v politicheskoy sfere sovremennogo rossiyskogo obshchestva: sotsiologicheskiy analiz: avtoref. diss. ... d-ra sotsiolog. nauk [Ryabova T. B. Gender stereotypes in the political sphere of modern Russian society: sociological analysis: avtoref. diss. ... Dr. sociologist. sciences]: 22.00.04. Nizhniy Novgorod, 2009. 42 p.

Adichie C. N. The danger of a single story. TEDGlobal 2009. URL: https://www.ted.com/talks/chimamanda_adichie_the_danger_of_a_single_story/transcript?language=en

Vedernikova I. Oksana Kis. Feminizm – tse pro liudei [Oksana Kis. Feminism is about people]. Dzerkalo tyzhnia, Mirror of the week. March 3, 2019. URL: https://dt.ua/interview/oksana-kis-feminizm-ce-pro-lyudey-304340_.html

Kozlova N. Gender kak instrument politologicheskogo analiza [Gender as a tool for political science analysis]. Puti i perspektivy integratsii gendernogo podkhoda v gumanitarnyye distsipliny [Ways and prospects of integrating a gender approach into humanitarian disciplines]: materialy konf. URL: http://fixed.ru/prikling/conf/gender/tezis2/gendeolohdly.html